What is your idea of a coherent ideology?
- 0 Posts
- 483 Comments
Hmm, if I stop one wolf from mauling one deer that’s less suffering for sure.
If we have to extend it to all such cases, it leads to interesting questions. How would we manage animal populations? How would we feed predators? Can these two goals be reached without suffering?
While the suffering is in some sense “natural”, it’s not clearly necessary. There was a time when some humans thought society couldn’t function without slaves, or with worker’s rights, or with women voting. But if we keep our minds open to ways of reducing suffering, we can find ways to make the world better.
A suffering-minimizing ideology. Given that animals are capable of suffering, and suffering is bad, it would be morally good to save an animal from being mauled to death.
SmoothOperatorto
News•‘It’s risky business emotionally’: the social shift towards open relationships
9·2 days agoWhat if you like to be in a committed relationship with one person and build a life together, developing deep emotional bonds over many years, but also enjoy having sex with many different people?
SmoothOperatorto
Lord Of The Rings Memes@lemmy.dbzer0.com•Orcs and Uruk-Hai discussing dinnerEnglish
83·3 days agoIt’s more like they barely know anything. Like toddlers or something.
SmoothOperatorto
Lord Of The Rings Memes@lemmy.dbzer0.com•Orcs and Uruk-Hai discussing dinnerEnglish
153·3 days agoIt’s actually pretty easy, many of them barely fight back
SmoothOperatorto
Peertube•Microsoft killed Win 10 support to rob you of your rights. Fight back by installing Linux.
2·5 days agoDamn… Can Windows really stop my BIOS from booting on a self built PC with TPM? How would my BIOS even know to not boot before Windows has started?
SmoothOperatorto
Peertube•Microsoft killed Win 10 support to rob you of your rights. Fight back by installing Linux.
1·6 days agoFor sure it didn’t just have to be, completely agree. But I find it hard to understand that that could be the only reason.
Is there really no way to steelman the requirement?
SmoothOperatorto
Peertube•Microsoft killed Win 10 support to rob you of your rights. Fight back by installing Linux.
2·6 days agoInteresting, thanks! How does TPM stop you from installing Linux? I haven’t had any issues with it.
SmoothOperatorto
Peertube•Microsoft killed Win 10 support to rob you of your rights. Fight back by installing Linux.
2·7 days agoIs it so trivially untrue? Could they just as easily have implemented TPM 2.0 in Win10 and just have stopped Win10 from working on devices without TPM 2.0 compatibility? Would that have been better?
SmoothOperatorto
Peertube•Microsoft killed Win 10 support to rob you of your rights. Fight back by installing Linux.
21·7 days agoIsn’t it, at least officially, to enforce TPM 2.0?
SmoothOperatorto
Today I Learned•TIL about the "Left-behind children" in China, due to the Hukou System, children were often left in their rural villages to be cared by relatives while the parents work in urban areas.English
3·7 days agoI agree. Is this “hukou system” is designed to keep people in their region? Does that mean they’re not building city schools on purpose?
Fucking elsker diæt-penge, kæmpe win win
SmoothOperatorto
Gaming•Me and my buddy on our Steam Decks on WW3 while waiting for the artillery barrage to finishEnglish
2·7 days ago“Made for playing games like Halo”, interesting description of the deck
SmoothOperatorto
Today I Learned•TIL about the "Left-behind children" in China, due to the Hukou System, children were often left in their rural villages to be cared by relatives while the parents work in urban areas.English
5·7 days agoI mean, if the schools are at capacity, what can you do? Other than building more schools of course.
SmoothOperatorto
Adventure / Point-n-Click / Narrative Games@retrolemmy.com•Cthulhu: The Cosmic Abyss gropingly squeezes its gelatinous green immensity onto PC in April 2026English
2·12 days agoGod bless rockpapershotgun’s verbose headings
Sounds like something the Suppression Bureau would say
The picture is the main character from Blade Runner 2049, who is in love with a digital woman that he loses when the harddrive she lives on is destroyed.
AWS means Amazon Web Services, the main cloud infrastructure of the world afaik. It recently had an outage, possibly erasing people’s AI partners.
SmoothOperatorto
Tycoon Games•Subway Builder, a "hyperrealistic" transit simulation/tycoon gameEnglish
3·17 days agoOnly American cities so far it seems



Thanks for answering, I broadly agree. But what about consistency?
A vegan might argue that eating meat is bad because it causes animal suffering. They would be morally required to save an animal from the butcher’s blade if given the chance (assuming they didn’t have to cause more suffering to do that).
But an animal doesn’t know the difference between being killed by a butcher and being killed by a predator. So is the vegan not also morally required to save an animal from a predator? If not, how is that consistent with the basis of their veganism? It sounds like an arbitrary distinction to me, hardly an element of a coherent ideology.
Of course, once extended from the single animal to all animals, there are nuances to consider. If the whole world went vegan this instant, that would have enormous ramifications on the meat industry, and what would we do with all those animals? It might not be moral to instantly turn the world vegan and just free all industrial animals due to the chaos that would ensue. But surely it would be moral to explore what processes could turn the world vegan in a less destructive way.