• 0 Posts
  • 168 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 25th, 2023

help-circle
  • I’ve only watched the first episode, I don’t know if I’ll watch the rest. I think I’ve hit on the key problem that this episode has: Interesting ideas, that it just doesn’t do anything interesting with. There are three key areas the episode could have focused on:

    • Translation. You have to be incredibly arrogant to assume you could instantly translate a language you’ve never spoken before. We get some hints of this but they never lead anywhere because the whole scene is cut off by the emergency alert and the cut to the news montage. The mistranslation we briefly see never has a chance to set in with any major down-the-line consequences. Even the reference to misgendering is a throwaway because there was never any danger of it leading to offence, and it comes across virtue signally more than having meaning. And I am very confused why the scene is directed as if this is the first time they’ve shared a dialogue, when there is loads of dialogue, equipment, and prior process to suggest they’ve already done this before.
    • Diplomacy. Similar to translation, we never get a chance for any misunderstandings, cultural shocks, subterfuge, political bargaining. We get a generic british diplomat who has to leave before we even get a chance to know him and his mindset. We get some obvious low hanging fruit about pollution, but without any serious discussion. I suspect this may come in later episodes, but this first one fails to make a big impression on this.
    • Gerry Anderson rube goldberg machines. The big tank forms a huge set piece. We get a very quick tease of a disaster scene, but it doesn’t lead anywhere. It fails to grip me with drama because there’s a sudden fear things are going to go wrong, only for the problem to immediately resolve without UNIT’s intervention itself when unnamed scaffold worker #3 tightens a bolt and fixes everything. If they wanted to play this up, they failed.

    Other gripes:

    • It starts with a dodgy CGI jumpscare, the soil liquefaction scene was honestly more terrifying, as something that can actually really happen in certain circumstances like earthquakes, but that only takes place about 10 minutes in. The liquefaction murder would have been a far more terrifying cold open that jumping in to a fishing boat monster. The story is being told from Barclay’s perspective, so I don’t think we should have seen any of the monster until the first time Barclay sees it in person.
    • The voices of many of the cast were far to mumbly, I needed subtitles early on. No nonsense army captain has a particularly low monotone voice.
    • The reference to the doctor didn’t need to be there, it didn’t contribute to the plot in any way. A spinoff needs to be able to stand on its own two feet. We already have UNIT, Kate, etc as the “hand over” characters, and I didn’t even see the whoniverse logo at the start, so I don’t know what the ultimate goal is there.
    • Another admin security failure from UNIT. They keep doing this. They’re supposed to be the toughest top level security force on the planet, and they can’t get a basic HR form right. I can suspend my disbelief for sea monsters and instant translation tech, but ‘I’m here by accident’ is just to much. The hand wavy “ah, but you’re the civilian we need here” doesn’t fix it.
    • Various minor writing issues. They “put the body far away from the village”? It’s literally in one of the houses next door. “I’m here by accident”, to which army guy immediately replies “So you’re saying you’re here by accident”. Why the deck chairs just to watch a loudspeaker blast some sound waves? Why is a helicopter carrying steel beams across london?

  • are you complaining that smaller devs get a bigger cut than larger devs? That’s certainly an interesting gripe…

    Smaller devs have to pay 30% of their revenues to steam. If a game sells well enough, their revenue share increases and steam takes a smaller cut, 25 or even 20%. This greatly benefits publishers of big games and unfairly punishes smaller developers. I think that’s a perfectly fair gripe.



  • The drivers run OK, but because they were not built for my distribution with the right flag, when I sleep and resume my system, I need to log out and back in to the desktop or else it bugs out.

    Is this the drivers fault for not having that be a default flag? The maintainers fault for not using the correct flags? Waylands fault for not interfacing with the driver right on resume? My fault for having the audacity to want to use the sleep function?

    I have no clue, but it doesn’t happen with the open source nouevau drivers, so I’m inclined to place a fair bit of the blame with nvidia.